- 1 In coming out as gay, Catholic priest sparks debate about church stance
- 2 St. Clair County court drug scandal widens to probation worker
- 3 Suspect in slayings of 5 in Illinois claims he killed killer
- 4 Longtime St. Louis criminal defense lawyer dies
- 5 Daughter comes forward for World War II medals found in Goodwill store
- 6 Belleville man accused of sexually assaulting two-year-old girl
- 7 Furlough Friday: Many in government had day off
- 8 St. Clair County judge held pending drug charge
- 9 Chelsea FC, police officer made boy's night a dream come true
- 10 Ill. House approves guns plan opposed by governor
Live Chats
Cardinals chat with Joe Strauss
Submit your Cardinals questions and opinions NOW; talk to Post-Dispatch baseball writer Joe Strauss at 1 p.m.

by Mike Smithon Oct 25, 2012 at 6:05 PM
-
We are Live!!! for your weekly sojourn into cyber-snark, journalistic excellence and occasional handicapping advice (a key element with Breeders Cup approaching). Per usual, the ChatHeads are salivating to ask their questions about all things Cardinals. By now you know Yadier Molina secured his fifth Gold Glove during Tuesday evening's interminable awards show. Just think you'll have several other similar shows as the BBWAA announces its awards later this month. But we digress. Let's climb the Big Wave and ride. An important (I think) announcement forthcoming. -
Hey Joe. Assuming the Cards make a qualifying offer to Lohse, what's the chances of him accepting? He obviously likes it here, but everybody assumes he is after years/AAV. Still, one year at 14 mil in the Loo certainly wouldn't damage his value next year, assuming health. -

-

-
I'm not sure. Trout is an outstanding defender. Adam Jones is also. Fans love to pile on scribes as know-nothings when the MVP, Cy Young and ROY awards are doled out in mid-November. Well, the Gold Gloves are voted upon by managers and coaches. Who is more qualified? I'm sure the same angst will surface in 2 weeks when Miguel Cabrera wins the AL MVP over Trout, who incidentally didn't reach Anaheim until a month into the season. -

-

-

-
I believe so. I don't envision a high-ticket acquisiton this winter. Berkman and Lohse coming off the books. Arbitration will drive up costs for numerous players. Scheduled raises will make up much of the remaining difference. I've seen some accounts of Cards payroll at $110M. I had it at about $116M before Opening Day. -

-

-

-
I haven't teased anything. I just re-tweeted that Drew opted out of his contract with the A's and is a free agent. He's long been a BFIB fetish. Drew has endured injuries and a sub-par year the last two seasons. His value is tricky. There is some unease about Furcal's elbow, though the club is presenting a confident face about his ability to avoid surgery. I believe a move will be made to address middle infield. The level of commitment is the question. With Wong approaching, Carpenter working out at the position and Descalso (and Kozma) capable defensively at second base, I envision any acquisition to be more SS-specific and shorter term. We'll see. -

-

-
Joe, Love the chat. Thank you for taking the time. Defense and Pitching is such a huge part of postseason baseball. The Giants proved it again this year. Last year we made some great plays that helped us win (minus the three errors in game 6). This year we were average at best. What can we do to improve defensively? SS upgrade anywhere in our future? -
The Cardinals are a pitching and power team. They are plus defensively at C, perhaps CF and at times at 2B. There isn't significant wiggle room for moves at other positions except adding depth at SS. Holliday became average at best in LF due to physical issues. The Cardinals love to talk about fundamentals and emphasis on fielding and baserunning but their lineup suggests a masher mentality. This season demonstrated that they didn't fare well when not driving the ball out of the park. The pitching was at times undermined by its defense. Lohse, in my opinion, had the most underrated season of any NL pitcher because of indifferent support. The Reds outperformed the Cardinals this season partly because of superior defense. There was a protracted stretch in which the Cardinals allowed five extra outs/bases per game. That's unacceptable. Kozma helped the situation in September but the situation remains an issue. -

-

-

-
Mozeliak assigned Matheny his coaching staff last winter. It's pretty obvious Mike has someone in mind with whom he would have more confidence in than Miller. That's his right. It is a shame when someone who has given an organization 20 years is suddenly put on the street. I'm not sure offering a Class A pitching coach job is a way to retain someone like Miller. It's the big leagues. It happens. But it's also too bad for Miller. -

-

-

-
Good question. Holliday has longstanding back issues that became more pronounced this season. Indeed, they first surfaced in spring training. His critics might weigh the fact that he was physically compromised for at least 2-3 months this year. Holliday has a violent swing that probably has something to do with the condition, or at least aggravating it. As with Furcal and Beltran, the Cardinals might examine being more proactive with Holliday's playing time. A game off every week or two may be beneficial to all of them. Carpenter allows them that flexibility in the outfield. A short-term fix at SS could allow them to do the same with Furcal. -

-

-

-

-

-
The club needs to find another LH pitcher somewhere. I don't think it's a necessity to have a LH starter to replace Garcia. Kelly proved himself capable for 2 months this season. However, there is an obvious need in the bullpen for LH depth. The Cardinals historically have gone cheap there. It may be time to step it up for more of a given than a Tallet or Romero. Rzep' was more of a question than a given this year as well. -
Mr. Strauss: I don't understand why any Cardinals fan would be upset over Jon Jay not being considered for a GG. I, personally, don't think he is an everyday player. His defense is pretty much average because of his arm strength and lack of foot speed. If Jay stole 40 bases or so, or if he had HR power, the Cardinals could live with him in CF. But he's neither fast, nor does he possess any power to speak of. That's why I wouldn't be surprised to see the Cardinals try to upgrade CF. -
Jay is cost-effective and became a plus defender and plus leadoff man. His home-road splits were perplexing. He also played with a weakened shoulder for much of the season. I long thought JJ a complementary OF because he lacked the power to play a flank and the arm to play center. However, he plays a fairly mature game. He's a resilient hitter who has grown into a leadership role in center. I don't know if he would fit with a less rebust offensive team. Here, it works, especially for the price tag. -

-

-
I remember you saying before the season that Furcal was a key to the success of 2012 (which was pretty accurate, really...when the SS was good, the Cards were very good). Anyway, care to take a stab at a player or two who could make or break 2013? Perhaps way to soon to say... -

-

-

-

-
Lynn has been told to arrive in spring training in better shape than he left St. Louis. The Cardinals went out of their way last week to say nothing is guaranteed the big man. I would think his playoff experience would motivate Lynn, who benefited from a combination of talent and terrific run support this season. It's a rare 18-game winner who is removed from the rotation in August and during the postseason. -

-

-

-
Albert has been in decline the last three years. However, he has declined from one of the top 10 hitters all-time to a guy who still exacts heavy damage. I noted several years ago that El Hombre had adopted more of a slugger's mentality. The club (well, TLR) chafed at the suggestion but I defy anyone to show otherwise. He has become less consistent, less willing to walk and needed more time to get going each season. All that said, I still consider Pujols one of the game's top 10 hitters. But when you were once universally acknowledged as No. 1, that represents a decline.
QUICK CLICKS
|
Archives |
Lottery |
DEALS, OFFERS AND EVENTS
Need help getting a car, truck, van or SUV?
We understand that bad things happen to good people. At Planet…
Check Out This 2008 Dodge Charger SRT8!! So Hot Its Smokin’
Victory Lane Ford is located in Litchfield, IL, 60 miles east …

Gateway Motorsports Park - Only $49 for a family 4 pack to USAC Traxxas Silver Crown Series at Gateway Motorsports Park in Madison IL!







Please Wait…